

The Daily Diatribe: The cry of despair from the small, uh, I mean, League clubs
By: Brian | March 21st, 2007Wow, I guess no one really gives a shit if Mourinho says it, but once Rafa reiterated the idea of having a ‘B team’ in the Football League, that shit hit the fan. Former Jockey and now Swindon Town Chairman Willie Carson doesn’t understand why Benitez would propose such a thing. Carson seems to think that the loaning out of players, how it’s been done forever, is the best way to develop players. I disagree since football is a team sport and players who learn to work the best together tend to be the better team. Learning the intricacies of your teammates’ game, their strengths and weaknesses and what you can do to make them a better player and vice versa is an integral part of the development process. It can take years to figure out another’s habits and abilities. How can they do that if one is at Stockport County, another is at Luton Town, a third is at Preston North End, and so on and so forth? Also throwing their two cents into the matter are Wonderbra campaign innovator and Brighton & Hove Albion chairman, Harry Richard ‘Dick’ Knight, the Peterborough director of football, Barry Fry, and former Sheffield United striker and current Mansfield Town head, Bill Dearden. Frankly, I find the short-sightedness and trepidation of their comments to be more alarming then Rafa’s. Insulting the history of the League? Laughable, save for a few top teams and a few great young players, most of the League is shit anyhow. Was that insulting enough for ya, Wonderbra-man? Barry Fry seems to think saying 16 million people attending 1728 games is impressive. For a comparison, the MLS, which I think is about on the same level as the Championship averages nearly twice per a game. Not impressive. He’s also out of his gourd if he doesn’t think LFC supporters wouldn’t go to watch a B team compete for something. Finally, we have Billy Dearden, who thinks plenty of players would be ‘out of work’ if this happens. I think he meant to say plenty of players that aren’t good enough to play in the higher levels of competition. If you’re shit, you’re shit, and that may be harsh, but who the hell wants to watch Johnny-down-the-street who can’t kick a ball into the ocean play? Let him go to school, get a degree, and start a Wonderbra campaign or something.
| EPL Match Schedule | Discount Travel to Liverpool | |||
| Liverpool Scores | Anfield information & hotels |
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments
-



MLS achieves that number with a handful of teams in a country of 300 million people in a league with little history bankrolled mainly by billionaires. England has supported around 90 league clubs for the best part of a hundred years, which is one of the reasons English football has such a unique and storied history. If English football is to be just about the interests of the top four clubs, you’re welcome to it, let Liverpool and Chelsea Reserves play each other to death.
Remember, before Bill Shankly arrived, Liverpool were just another “shit” club in the lower divisions. It was Shankly who said “The socialism I believe in is everybody working for the same goal and everybody having a share in the rewards. That’s how I see football, that’s how I see life.” What a nutter, eh?
Posted from
United States

-



Um, Liverpool won 5 First Division Championships before Shankly arrived in 1959, if that’s a ’shit’ club in the ‘lower divisions’, you just pretty much called the history of English football a bunch of turds whirling around the toilet.
Posted from
United States

-



Liverpool were in the second division when Shankly arrived (they remained outside the first division from 1954-62) and hadn’t won the league since 1947, and wouldn’t again until 1964. So they were in a similar position to the many fallen giants in the Football League today, who you (not me) dismiss as all being “shit”.
By reducing the Football League to letting the elite clubs reserve teams in, you take away all hope from football outside of the top clubs, who will never be able to rise the way Liverpool once did, as it will just grow the gap between the richest and the rest.
I can’t believe you actually think football does not matter outside of the Premiership elite’s interests, nor that those who loyally support their local teams should all worship Liverpool or Chelsea on TV. How about those that can’t afford a season ticket at Anfield or Stamford Bridge? And who would you play in the F.A. Cup? Do you want just four teams to exist in England?
Posted from
United States

-



No, read what I wrote again, I did not dismiss them all as ’shit’. I wrote ’save for a few top teams and a few great young players, most of the League is shit anyhow.’ Sorry, that’s life. If they were so good they’d be in the Premiership.
Plus the b teams suggested by Benitez and Mourhino would not be eligible for promotion, like the big club b teams in Spain, for instance. And gosh, what a horrible idea to try to make the Football League better as a whole by increasing the talent level and hence, the level of competition. Don’t want that.
Posted from
United States

-



“If they were so good they’d be in the Premiership.”
Well, given there’s only 20 teams ever in the Premiership, that’s pretty redundant. The rest of the league could be better than everyone else in the world, and there would still only be 20 teams in the Premiership, so there’s nothing to say about that.
In other countries where top league teams have B teams in the lower divisions, it devalues those lower divisions - Real Madrid B aren’t allowed to be promoted. What has traditionally been fun about English football has been the pyramid structure, the F.A. cup, etc.
This year’s Championship race is a hell of a lot of fun (more fun than the same teams competing for the Premiership again), but if Chelsea B were in there confusing everything by winning all their games but not being promoted and with players financed by a Russian billionaire no-one else could compete with, would it really be fun at all?
Posted from
United States

Comments are closed
















