Liverpool Capture Stewart Downing

By: Noel | July 13th, 2011
   
stewart downing liverpool transfer

In the end, Liverpool get the man they’ve been chasing since the transfer window opened. They get the man who was caught holding up a Liverpool scarf in Spain with Andy Carroll three weeks ago. It will cost the club up to £20M—with, as always, the “up to” being of key importance—an improved offer on the £15M they reportedly bid earlier in the week. It’s also worth noting that in between the fee Aston Villa turned down and the one they accepted today, Stewart Downing reportedly handed in a written transfer request.

In the odd world of football transfers, handing in a transfer request means a player gives up any loyalty bonuses he would be due to receive if sold on against his wishes by the club. In theory it’s rather sensibly about making it so that a club has to pay off a player that doesn’t want to move on—a form of job protection. In practice at the highest levels it means that players hardly ever hand in transfer requests, agitating for a move personally or through agents and the media while awaiting an extra pay day if they don’t put into writing that they want out.

For Downing, handing in that request—and in so doing forfeiting a pile of money that would likely allow the average fan to take the next five or ten years (or more) off to do nothing but follow their club around—is a sign of just how much he wanted to join Liverpool. No matter one’s personal opinion of the Villa wide midfielder and winger, that’s worthy of note. And with that in mind, as well as when one considers how long the saga has dragged on, it’s hard to imagine the player won’t quickly pass his medical and agree to terms now that the tricky transfer fee has been sorted.

When it comes to fees, too, it’s also worth remembering that while many will consider Downing’s excessive, it was Downing and not recent £16M Manchester United acquisition Ashley Young who was in fact Villa’s player of the season last term. Downing also had two years left on his contract compared to Young’s one, and many would consider Downing’s tendency to play a larger role in build-up play than United’s new and fairly direct winger another point in his favour given Liverpool’s stated desire to fully embrace a pass and move game. When it comes to hard returns, Liverpool’s newest player registered seven goals and seven assists for Aston Villa last season, a haul placing him second on the team in both categories behind Bent (9 goals) and Young (10 assists). It’s a return that would have seen him fourth in goals for Liverpool (Kuyt 13, Maxi 10, Torres 9) and tied for first in assists with Kuyt.

Like fellow new arrival Jordan Henderson, Downing’s best qualities can at times be easy to overlook and largely stand to counter the typical causes of grumbling over paying English premiums for overrated talent. In short, he’s a technically sound but simple player who possess a football brain. He has decent pace but won’t burn past one defender after another all day long; he has a great first touch with his left foot and mostly sticks to knocking the ball one way and using a powerful short burst to buy room for a cross. He’ll track back and make the smart passes and, at times, be accused of simply not being flashy enough—or of not being the huffing, puffing, all action and no plot stereotypical English footballer. As put by Barney Ronay in the Guardian recently, Downing is an oddity in the English game, the sort of player likely to be appreciated by those who want to build “a team around neat, skilful, hard-working players rather than false prophets and self‑propelling celebrities.”

Another similarity he has with Jordan Hernderson is that last season he made 78 passes that created goal scoring chances, tying him with the former Sunderland man at third in the league in that category. However, that as a player counted on to take the bulk of his side’s set pieces and corners, as well as being a frequent provider of crosses, his 72.2% pass completion rate is rather closer to Charlie Adam’s 69.6% than Henderson’s 77.8% is cause for some concern.

Still, setting aside any reservations that come about almost entirely due to what seems a high fee, it’s hard to argue that based on Liverpool’s needs Downing isn’t the right man for the job—or at the very least a good option for it. Names hailing from elsewhere might carry more cachet, but they would also lack his Premier League experience. And they also didn’t hand in a transfer request, telling the world that more than anything else they wanted to join Liverpool Football Club.

While people will argue over whether Jordan Henderson is almost entirely a name for the future, or whether Charlie Adam is an automatic starter in a crowded Liverpool midfield not short on quality, it’s hard to image Stewart Downing isn’t the one signing to date in this summer window who will walk directly into the first eleven as it currently stands. Like Albert Riera before him, Liverpool’s last genuine wide player on the left, he may not seem to be particularly exceptional at any one thing—but he’s at least solid at just about everything he’ll be asked to do. And like Riera before his personal issues led to a falling out with the club, it’s hardly a stretch to think Downing’s signing will greatly improve the team even if it’s not as flashy a name as some might like.

In the end, it’s that and not the fee or Youtube stepovers that matter. He’s a player who will improve the squad, full stop. That’s all that matters.

Note: You can find more Stewart Downing match compilations on the always exceptional FootyLounge


Some Related Liverpool Posts:


Tags

   
  • Sampath

    What a terrible, terrible signing. Another overpaid English player. Can get better player for 5-10 million less. You guys got ripped of BAD.

  • Ryan

    ooh. He can make Pantsil score on Fulham! Downing will fit well in with our strategy. Not even Riise will be able to stop the power of Rodriguez, Downing, and Pantsil. 

    Well, I like him. I much preferred Ashley Young, but now, I'll leave that all behind me and say that I've been following Downing since Middlesbrough. What number will he be taking? Not that it matters, I just gotta update my FIFA 11 liverpool team. You know..

  • Russell

    I think i heard he'll be number 19, but that's not confirmed.

  • Seanster

    Got to say I'm getting happier by the day with the way this transfer window is unfolding. Had the misfortune of travelling to Middlesborough a couple of years ago when they beat us 2-0 in the season they were relegated and Downing was head an shoulder above everyone on the pitch. That stuck in my head, not much else does at the best of times.

    Isn't it strange how us fans have become obsessed with fee's and wages and the like the last few years. Serious debate on the value of players before a balls been kicked, the mass negative hysteria over Henderson's fee was something to behold.

    For a long time we've a manager universally loved with owners willing to back his decision making to the hilt. We all seem terrified that we're actually paying big fee's for players when for years we've bemoaned not going the extra and missing out on targets. Maybe the well publicised financial cockballing of the two cowboys have got us overly paranoid. Befor the Moores/Cowboy regimes we'd a history of backing our managers financially and seem thankfully to have reverted to type.

    I for one am like a kid on Christmas eve, enjoying trying to figure where we're going to fit in these new players and have decided not to worry one iota about how we're going to get Poulson off our wage bill. The Americans obviously have a few bob and trust Kenny so lets enjoy the ride.

  • Guest

    20 mill you have got to be kidding. I don't know, we have 3 players with no resale value at all  now Downing, Carroll and Henderson. I am sorry and I pray I'm wrong but in KK I don't trust.

  • NOLAred

    How do you figure that Carroll and Henderson don't have any resale value? They are both young and English, so that right there gives them resale value. Downing is in his prime now and we should get 3-4 good years out of him at least, filling a need that we've had since Riera left, so in his case resale value shouldn't even enter the equation. Hendo and Carroll have all the tools to contribute to our side for years to come, which is why we bought them in the first place. We shouldn't care about there resale values because both of them should cement places in our side for the foreseeable future. How can you be so pessimistic after the last off season we had where we were buying the likes of Poulsen and Konchesky? If we want to get back to consistently pushing for the title, we need to build a team with depth and that's exactly what we've been doing since FSG took over.

  • KK as in Kevin Keegan?

  • Andy

    Gotta also say that since his start at AVFC in 2009 there was only one game Downing didn't start.  Great consistency which is something we desperately need after the injury prone players we seem to attract.

    I'm happy with our signings so far this season, but when the hell are we going to offload some of these players and their wages?  I mean honestly it's not like anyone is going to be drooling over Joe Cole and Poulsen.  I wish we could just release the players.  Who cares about getting a return on their fees and wages at this point.  We have so many midfielders now that I have trouble remembering them all.  It's getting rather frightening.

    I'm still worried about a left back too.  God knows I love Aurelio when he's fit, but he can't even be a reliable back up.  And with Carragher aging and Agger's injury woes (he better be goddamned fit this season) it's tough to be confident in this defense.  Sure we got the youngsters but you've said it and we all know how easy it is to burn these kids out, and that's the last thing we need.

  • ChrisO

    Katie, I seem to remember that NUFC claimed that Carroll submitted a request, which was denied by Carroll/his agent. I suspect that Newcastle made the claim in order to save Mike Ashley and the rest of the Board from the righteous anger of the rampaging Toon horde looking for revenge over the sale of the latest Great Geordie Saviour. Also, it was reported that Newcastle had valued Carroll at about 2mil the previous summer, and he had only recently made it into the first team from the youth setup, so I doubt there would be any significant loyalty bonus due anyway.

    I would guess that a selling club could always ask a player to forgo such a bonus as part of negotiations in a move that a player/agent had agitated for - cf. Modric or Fabregas currently. It would be interesting to discover if such a thing had happened without the formal transfer request in similar transfers previously.

  • Yann

    Doesn’t Mata that we signed Downing. Dalglish’s history
    shows that he likes to build teams that are greater than the sum of their
    parts. All the signings have a great work ethic and are proven EPL performers. To
    my mind this is not Kenny rolling dice, he knows exactly what he’s doing and a
    top three finish will have Liverpool bringing in triple what they’ve spent. 

  • lfc80uk

    I guess the stats don't lie. But we have to ask ourselves three questions. Firstly does Downing provide numerous assists? Yes! Will he get lots of goals for Andy Carroll via his hippy styled bonce? Yes! Have LFC again been forced to pay a premium price for yet another overpriced British player? Yes!

    The answer to the last question is probably the one that irks me the most as well as a majority of other LFC fans. Stuart Downing for me is not worth more than £10-12 million at the most! I am sure we have all thought that if we had offered another £5 million pound we could have signed Juan Mata, Bastos, Turan etc! Me too!

    However, this article may explain further reasons for LFC signing Downing. Enjoy!

    http://www.football365.com/f36...

    ps your article was great as well Noel :)

  • Guest

    So if we stick with the 4-2-2-2 formation featured prominently at the end of last season (or 4-2-2-1-1 as Joel described it), we have:

    1. Carroll, Kuyt, Suarez as a 3-man rotation occupying the two forward spots.

    2. Adam, Lucas, Gerrard as a 3-man rotation in the two holding midfield/volantes spots.

    3. Aquilani, Downing, Henderson, Maxi and Meireles all competing for the two attacking midfield/meias spots.

    This, ladies and gentleman, is depth. And what a blessed thing it is. Still, I will persist in weeping over a carton of vanilla ice cream and crying out "REESAH!!!!" because we could probably use another left-footed fullback.

  • Ed

    You're not grieving correctly if you're not screaming "RELEASE THE KRAKEN!!!"

  • paul

    Lucas won't get a starting place if he comes back with his poor Copa performances. The only positive from him this summer is he's now looking up and forward, then making the rare quality through-ball pass. He's looking very static and particularly slow in that yellow shirt. I can't tell whether he's burned out from the domestic season, or whether the rest of the side are like mental cats.

  • Avinash Joshi

    After seeing the transfers of this window. I am getting the feeling that a man gets who goes all in on a flush draw and the river is about to open. All of them are huge gambles and it can go both ways. As the line has been touted loads of times before, "In kenny we trust". 

  • Toucan

    Your article damned Downing with faint praise

  • brother jon

    and that 'highlight' clip (admittedly, from one match) didn't help his cause either. still, the whole >> the parts.

  • Geza

    Hard worker, skilled, extensive PL experience, fills a big gap in the squad AND wanted to play for us...that says it all....good signing, especially considering that the net investment so far has been reasonable considering what FSG has promised.

  • Mike

    FSG moneyball + no CL footy + holy crap he is desperate to be a red = good signing. And compared to last season's summer transfer window, we're doing very good. Now maybe a defensive signing, and a backup striker...although I would love for Pacheco to play that role.

  • I have a question about transfer requests, since I apparently knew nothing about them until reading this post (thanks Noel!).  Maybe I'm remembering things incorrectly, but didn't Newcastle get Carroll to submit a transfer request in part to justify selling him to Liverpool?  How can a club ask a player to submit a request if it involves giving up their loyalty bonus?

    Please correct me if I'm wrong about these events; it wouldn't be the first time, and it certainly won't be the last. 

  • paul

    Because the same player gets a massive signing on bonus the other side. All parties are greedy. The player want a leaving bonus and a new signing bonus at the same time. The selling club wants to keep as much of the incoming money as possible, and the agents go squealing to the bank in joy.

    Carroll wanted a better contract, didn't care where, but was hoping the Toons would rush into one when we put in the initial offer. Toons weren't going to do that, he'd just signed a better one after all, so Carroll got upset because mega-money was nearby and had his agent whispering in his ear a few times. How can someone recently signing a new contract expect a *loyalty* bonus when they want out? Carroll could have simply said "not going" and refused to speak to LFC, but he didn't. The lure of the sponds was too high.

  • Antonio

    How about Lenon combination with Downing?
    It has been too long with see speedy winger for Liverpool. Downing seem to operate well at the right side being a left footed. Hopefully that will mean we don't see Raul has to shift to the right position anymore.
    2 very left footed player signed so far. I think we paying rather high price so far on the signing, I guess being British players it is that expensive, I heard the commentators of the Guangdong TV mentioned that British players are over-valued in BPL.
    In the position we in, I suppose so-call world cup players are not likely to join us at the moment, even we have the cash to spend.
    My concern now is that if we don't off load some surplus players, players wages will post a problem.

    Anyway, hope the joining of Downing, will Down some of the Big guns next season. Good Luck.

  • Guest

    Hey Antonio we still don't have any speed after spending 100mill I can see a 6th place finish on the cards (I hope I'm wrong) because we have only signed one player which has the skill to turn a game (Suarez).
    P.S I do like Adam though very tough and has passion.

  • I feel compelled yet again to say that Noel, Ed, and Nate of Oh You Beauty write such awesome posts that it feels as if my brain's best thoughts has been professionally mined, extracted, and typed in the exact linguistic form I'd want them to be, if I had any skills at written football commentary. It's uncanny!

    Anyways, the Downing pickup legitimately feels like the cherry on top of a terrific Liverpool transfer season.  We didn't end up overspending or underspending, we didn't focus only on midfielders, and Dalglish seems to have a generally positive grand plan to bring us back to European glory.

    Not only that, Joe Cole was pretty much the instigator of TWO goals today.  Does anyone else smell Club World Cup??

  • Khaine

    So I guess chance creation is the name of the stat game then. Our three signings this summer combined for (depending on where you get your stats) roughly 230 chances created last season. No way that is a coincidence.

    Also, that takes our spending under FSG to a cool 100m. Or about 40m net. Which gets you a striking partnership of Berba and Bebe, or one shiny new Edin Dzeko. Just to put some perspective on it for the clowns who are comparing Liverpool with Man City.

    So, for those who aren't exhausted yet, who's the next ITK sure thing?

blog comments powered by Disqus

Follow Us

           




England National Team News

Search The Offside


 




Related Links


Categories


Send Your Tips!

Found a great story, photo or video that's perfect for The Offside?
Email liverpool[at]theoffside[dot]com

Write for The Offside

Archives